词源 |
Cretan n.Old English Cretense (plural), "natives or inhabitants of Crete, from Latin Cretanus (singular); see Crete. They were proverbial in ancient times as liars; compare Greek noun kretismos "lying," literally "Cretan behavior," and the classical sophism expressing the liar paradox (see one version below). Alternative Cretic (c. 1600) was used especially of a form of verse. Epimenides, the Cretan, says that all Cretans are liars. If Epimenides' statement is not true, he is a liar; and if it is true, he is a liar, for he is a Cretan. But his statement is either true or not true. Therefore he is a liar. But since he is a liar, his statement is not true that all Cretans are liars. Therefore some Cretans are not liars. But since some Cretans are not liars, Epimenides is not necessarily a liar because he is a Cretan. Therefore, we may accept his statement that all Cretans are liars. And so on. [John J. Toohey, "An Elementary Handbook of Logic," 1918] updated on September 29, 2018 |